Sherwood Forest may be best known for its tree-lined streets and peaceful, tucked-away vibe, but this small Atlanta neighborhood punches well above its weight in the food scene. Bordering the energetic Midtown and Ansley Park, Sherwood Forest offers easy access to some of the city’s most popular dining clusters—while cultivating its own cozy collection of cafés, bakeries, and restaurants that locals swear by. Whether you’re in the mood for locally roasted coffee, inventive Southern cuisine, or just a sweet treat in a friendly setting, this neighborhood has a surprise waiting for you.
The Heartbeat: The Monroe Drive Corridor
If you ask any Sherwood Forest regular where to start your culinary journey, they’ll likely send you to the Monroe Drive corridor. Just steps from the intersection with Piedmont Avenue, Monroe Drive forms the artery of the neighborhood’s food life.
- Sublime Doughnuts (535 10th St NW at Monroe Dr.) — A legendary Atlanta institution, Sublime Doughnuts serves up creative takes on the classic treat. Favorites include the Fresh Strawberry N Cream and A-Town Cream—perfect for a sweet breakfast or a late-night snack. Prices sit at $2–$4 per doughnut, and don’t miss their locally roasted coffee to pair with your pick.
- Caribou Coffee (1014 Monroe Dr. NE) — This bright corner café is a gathering spot for locals who want high-quality coffee and a spot to get some work done. It’s spacious, friendly, and offers a selection of baked goods and sandwiches—great for a casual brunch or meeting.
- Fellini’s Pizza (1634 McLendon Ave. NE, near Monroe Dr.) — Just east on McLendon (a quick drive from Sherwood Forest’s center), this Atlanta pizza staple never disappoints. Their New York-style pies are beloved for their crispy crust and fresh toppings. Expect a laid-back vibe and a patio that buzzes in the evenings. A large cheese pizza runs about $18, with generous slices for grab-and-go.
Local Favorites & Hidden Gems
Venture a bit off the main drag, and you’ll find some tucked-away treasures that keep Sherwood Forest’s foodies very happy.
- Smith’s Olde Bar (1578 Piedmont Ave. NE) — While technically on the edge of Sherwood Forest, no local food guide is complete without mentioning Smith’s. This iconic Atlanta venue and eatery is famous for its music scene as much as its kitchen. Try the chicken tenders or the veggie burger, and wash it down with local craft beer. Entrées cost $11–$18, and the vibe is unpretentious and warmly nostalgic.
- Timothy’s Gourmet Deli (1371 Piedmont Ave. NE) — A true hidden gem, Timothy’s serves up some of the best sandwiches in the city. Their turkey club is loaded and satisfying, while salads and soups make for a perfect quick lunch. With prices around $8–$12, you’ll leave both happy and full.
- Cafe Intermezzo (1065 Peachtree St. NE, a quick drive south) — For those seeking a European vibe, this spot is worth the short trip down Peachtree. The pastry case is alluring, the coffee selection is robust, and the late-night hours invite conversation over decadent desserts. Average desserts are $7–$10, making it a perfect date spot or an after-dinner treat.
Best Brunches & Breakfasts
Sherwood Forest residents are brunch aficionados, and the neighboring blocks to this community know how to deliver.
- Highland Bakery Midtown (1180 Peachtree St. NE, in the vicinity) — Expect a wait on weekends, but the cornmeal pancakes and house-made cinnamon rolls are worth every minute. Famous for creative twists on Southern classics, prices range from $9–$16.
- Egg Harbor Cafe (1020 Piedmont Ave. NE) — With a bright, sunlit dining room and a menu that never disappoints, this cafe is a crowd-pleaser for both locals and visitors. Their signature breakfast skillets and fresh-pressed juices make mornings better. Expect $10–$15 for most brunch dishes.
Quick Bites & Food Trucks
When you’re in a rush or want something fun and on-the-go, Sherwood Forest delivers with casual eats and the occasional food truck pop-up.
- Farm Burger (1017 Piedmont Ave. NE) — Burger fans flock to Farm Burger for grass-fed patties, unique toppings, and hand-cut fries. A burger runs about $9, and add-ons like pimento cheese or a fried egg let you make it your own.
- Food Trucks at Ansley Mall (1544 Piedmont Ave. NE) — While technically in neighboring Ansley, the food truck events here frequently attract Sherwood Forest residents. Look for BBQ, tacos, and dessert trucks—rotating vendors keep things fresh and exciting.
Sweet Treats & Bakeries
Don’t sleep on dessert—Sherwood Forest offers options for every kind of sweet tooth.
- Krispy Kreme (295 Ponce De Leon Ave., a short drive east) — Sure, it’s a well-known chain, but the “Hot Now” sign draws devotees from across the city. Grab a dozen classic glazed after dinner or for a weekend breakfast treat.
- Alon’s Bakery & Market (1394 North Highland Ave. NE) — A European-style bakery and market just a few minutes away, Alon’s is a must-visit for pastries, cookies, and artisanal bread. The café offers sandwiches and coffee, too, if you want to linger.
Local Food Traditions
Sherwood Forest loves hyperlocal, community-driven food traditions. Residents often gather for block parties and neighborhood potlucks, where everyone brings a favorite dish, drawing from both Southern comfort classics and international inspirations. During spring and fall, look for the Sherwood Forest Food Crawl, when local businesses offer tastings and special menus for a night of culinary exploration within walking distance.
Closing Thoughts
Sherwood Forest isn’t just a leafy residential neighborhood—it’s a culinary playground for anyone who loves great food in an inviting, unfussy atmosphere. Whether you’re a long-time resident or just passing through, make time to explore the coffee shops, bakeries, pizza joints, and hidden gems sprinkled throughout the area. You’ll discover flavors—and local characters—that keep Atlanta’s unique neighborhoods thriving.